Skip to Main Content
The Hamilton Project
The Hamilton Project
  • Newsletter Signup
  • News and Commentary
  • Brookings
  • Topics
    • Economic Security & Inequality
    • Education
    • Effective Government
    • Employment & Wages
    • Energy & Climate
    • Health Care
    • Healthy Economy
    • Housing & Infrastructure
    • Immigration
    • Recessions
    • Social Insurance
    • Tax Policy & Budget
    • Technology & Innovation
  • Publications
  • Data
  • Events
  • About
    • Mission and Vision
    • Advisory Council
    • Staff
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Search
All Publications
Share
[addthis tool="addthis_inline_share_toolbox"]
Policy Proposals

Modernizing SNAP benefits

By: James P. Ziliak
May 20, 2016
Social Insurance
Full Paper

Problem

The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) is an effective program that prevents millions of families from becoming food insecure;  however, the current benefit allocations are based on increasingly outdated assumptions, including unreasonable expectations about households’ availability of time to prepare food, and need to be modernized.

Proposal

A time adjustment factor, increasing maximum SNAP benefit levels by 20 percent, would be introduced to offset unrealistic expectations for time use. Subsequently, a comprehensive reform of the maximum benefit allotment would be conducted, which would introduce geographic price adjustments, allow for cost variability over time, expand from its current, overly narrow sample the comparison group over which example consumption patterns are drawn, and account for heightened food needs of teenagers. The USDA would also conduct research to support its ability to implement the first two stages of the proposal.

Abstract

The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), formerly known as the Food Stamp Program, is the largest food assistance program in the United States. The goal of SNAP is to alleviate food insecurity and improve nutrition by helping lowincome households purchase food to prepare at home. SNAP benefits are provided monthly to eligible households, based on a maximum benefit determined by the cost of a food budget known as the Thrifty Food Plan (TFP). However, the TFP assumes that low-income households can spend an unlimited amount of time preparing food from scratch and has consequently shifted toward the food items that are lowest cost but most time-intensive.

Ziliak proposes a three-stage approach to improving the adequacy of SNAP benefits by modernizing the TFP. In the first stage, the estimated cost of the TFP would be immediately increased by twenty percent to partially account for the cost of time spent on food preparation. Next, the USDA would further reform the TFP to address features that distort the composition of the grocery cart, including geographic variation in food prices, the 1970s-set cap on the inflation-adjusted value of SNAP benefits, the TFP’s excessively narrow focus on low-income households, and the lack of consideration for the dietary needs of teenagers. Finally, he proposes a specific research agenda to support the first two stages. The proposal would bring the assumptions underlying SNAP benefit levels in line with current norms of food consumption and time use, thus strengthening the effectiveness of SNAP in addressing food insecurity and other health and nutrition outcomes.

Full PaperpdfPolicy Briefpdf

Related Links

Fiscal policy reconsidered
Strengthening Temporary Assistance for Needy Families
Nine facts about the Great Recession and tools for fighting the next downturn

Contact

Media Inquiries

Este Griffith
Phone: 202-238-3088
[email protected]

Author

James P. Ziliak

Gatton Endowed Chair in Microeconomics, Department of Economics, University of Kentucky; Director, Center for Poverty Research, University of Kentucky

Related Content

Shopping cart on curb
Data

SNAP payment error rates by state, FY 2003–24

Shopping cart on curb
Paper

Proposed SNAP cuts would permanently undermine recession readiness and responsiveness

Shopping cart on curb
Data

Assessing SNAP work requirement waiver policies

Contact Us

THP Newsletter

Stay up to date with The Hamilton Project by signing up to receive the newsletter.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright 2025 The Brookings Institution. Terms and Conditions. Build by Social Driver.

  • Topics
    • Economic Security & Inequality
    • Education
    • Effective Government
    • Employment & Wages
    • Energy & Climate
    • Health Care
    • Healthy Economy
    • Housing & Infrastructure
    • Immigration
    • Recessions
    • Social Insurance
    • Tax Policy & Budget
    • Technology & Innovation
  • Publications
  • Data
  • Events
  • About
    • Mission and Vision
    • Advisory Council
    • Staff
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Search
  • Newsletter Signup
  • News and Commentary
  • Brookings
Close Modal
Close Modal
close modal icon
This website uses cookies to offer you a better experience. By continuing on the site, you agree to the use of cookies.Agree